Movie Reviews

iReview the iCarly Reboot

Last Thursday, Paramount Plus released a brand new iCarly reboot. With four episodes and more on the way, it’s a nostalgic blend of past and present, childhood and adulthood. Carly says it best in the show itself: “This is still iCarly, but it’s grown up now.” But that may just be their downfall.

Carly in the iCarly reboot
Photo: Newsweek

It starts off with a couple of changes. There’s new characters, missing cast members, and a new show format, and the first episode spends a lot of time trying to explain it all.

Carly, it seems, never really found anything more fulfilling than iCarly. She went to college, got a job, got a boyfriend, but it just didn’t feel right. Freddie failed a couple of tech startups and two marriages. Spencer got rich.

The most obvious difference, though, is that Sam is missing.

Carly, Spencer, and Freddie in the original iCarly show
Photo: TV Line

Sometime during the nine years that have passed, Sam ran off with a biker gang. Instead, there’s Harper, a new character. She’s a much different character, but her role as Sam’s replacement is clear; Carly even calls her her BFSS (Best Friend Since Sam) in episode four.

Harper is the embodiment of a millennial. Or at least, what the new iCarly writers think a millennial would be like. She’s a barista who wants to be a fashion designer. In the first episode, her main personality trait is that she’s hot and into everyone.

Harper and Millicent in the iCarly reboot
Photo: Cinema Blend

Another new character, Millicent, also joins the cast. She’s the token Gen Z kid: an influencer wannabe who thinks all the grown-ups are lame. Oh, and she’s also Freddie’s adopted daughter.

All those changes are a bit abrupt, and the pilot’s acting and dialogue seem unnatural because of it. They rely on nostalgia, bringing back old bits and old characters, but make it “grown up” by drinking wine and swearing. The old iCarly was great, there’s no denying it, but being the same show a decade later isn’t possible. 

Once the reboot figures that out, I think it could be just as good, if not better.

Cover photo courtesy Teen Vogue

About author

Articles

Annie Burba is a sophomore at New York University studying journalism and psychology. She spends her spare time reading, scrolling through TikTok, and trying not to kill her plants.
    Related posts
    Movie Reviews

    A Review of the Gossip Girl Reboot

    Fans of the 2007-2012 hit Gossip Girl, starring Blake Lively, Leighton Meester and Penn Badgley…
    Read more
    Movie Reviews

    Bo Burnham 'Inside' is Hilariously Heartbreaking

    After a year of finding escapism in binge-watching during a pandemic, Bo Burnham decided to turn the…
    Read more
    Movie Reviews

    10 Most Wholesome Friends Moments

    The characters on Friends made us laugh and cry, all while showing us what it’s like to be a…
    Read more
    Newsletter
    Join The Special Circle

    Keep it POPPING with POP Style TV !

    Interviews

    All About K POP With Emerson Unger

    Worth reading...